Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Information literacy ~Astronomy - Chemistry - Mathematics - Physics: Evaluation criteria: relevance and reliability

Relevance

‘Relevance’ means the extent to which the information helps you to answer the research question. You assess the information on the basis of format, content and currency.

Content and level of the information

Does the information relate to the research question and the aim of your research?

 Ask yourself the following questions:

  • Does the information answer my research question?
  • Are the quality and level of the information appropriate to my research and the aim of the research? If you are conducting academic research into depression, an article from Cosmopolitan or Hello! will not provide information of the standard you require. Articles from academic journals are more appropriate. (See the chapter 'Choosing information sources')

How complete is the information you have found?

Are you sure you haven‘t overlooked any relevant information? Have you considered all the selected opinions? Being comprehensive is usually not possible and also usually not necessary.

The form of the information

Have you chosen the right type of source (book, article, thesis, etc.) for the information you need?

If you are looking for background information, it may be better to look at a book or website rather than an in-depth research article. If you are writing a light-hearted article (e.g. for National Geographic), you won’t need to read PhD theses. For more information, see the chapter 'Choosing information sources'.

Currency

The term ‘current’ usually refers to recent events or developments. In order to determine whether information is current, check whether it still reflects the present situation. A book or article that was not written recently may still be current. Publications that remain current and relevant are known as ‘core publications’.

Usually current information is required, but not always. The importance of this criterion depends on your research question.

Reliability

This refers to how sure you can be that the information is correct. How credible is the information? How objective is the information? There are several aspects to take into consideration when you are assessing how reliable your information is. These aspects relate to the origin of the information as well as its quality.

Authority of the source (author/organization) and origin of the document

  • What do you know about the author? Is he an authority on the subject? Is he a recognized author in his subject area? Which organization does he work for?
  • What do you know about the organization? Publications by well-known and respected organizations are generally more reliable than material published by vague charitable foundations with dubious or unclear objectives.
  • Does the author or organization receive funding from sponsors? Sponsorship is not necessarily a problem, but be aware of any commercial interests that may be involved.
  • Is the quality of the publication assessed? If so, is this done by editors? Are articles peer reviewed?  Peer-reviewed articles are very reliable because they have been critically assessed by more than one expert/academic.

Content

Accuracy

  • Are the supposedly factual descriptions correct? Check whether they are backed up by information in other sources.
  • Are opinions supported by facts?

Objectivity

  • Is informing the reader the author's primary goal, or is he rather trying to persuade his audience? (Opinion-forming, propaganda, etc.)
  • Is the information based on hard facts or on opinions?
  • Is the subject explored from different perspectives?

Verifiability

  • Are source references provided?
  • What is the quality of the cited sources?
  • Is it possible to verify whether the information is correct and complete?

Checklist for evaluating information and information sources

The CRAAP test is a useful checklist for evaluating information and information sources.